Divided Views on Immigration – How America is Reacting to New Border Policies in 2025

By Searchpanda - January 23, 2025

As President Donald Trump embarks on his second term, immigration policies, particularly those affecting the U.S.-Mexico border, have become focal points of national debate. According to a recent survey from The Associated Press-NORC Center for Public Affairs Research, a significant portion of U.S. adults agree that enhancing border security and carrying out targeted deportations should be prioritized. However, the comprehensive approach taken by the administration suggests that America’s consensus on immigration may be narrower than it appears.

Divided Views on Immigration: How America is Reacting to New Border Policies in 2025
Exploring the Divide: America’s Stance on Immigration and Border Control

A Closer Look at Border Security Priorities

The data reveals a clear inclination among Americans to tighten security at the southern border. Approximately half of the respondents view increasing border security as a high priority for the federal government, with about three in ten considering it a moderate priority. This perspective is less about sealing the border completely and more about managing it effectively to curb illegal activities and unauthorized crossings.

Despite the prevailing view favoring stronger border measures, President Trump’s policies, including keeping asylum-seekers in Mexico and challenging the automatic citizenship provision, indicate a more aggressive stance than many Americans support.

The Public’s Stance on Deportations

The survey underscores a strong public approval for deporting immigrants convicted of violent crimes, a starting point for the Trump administration’s deportation efforts. Yet, the policy’s extension to potentially deport millions poses a divisive dilemma. About 40% of American adults support deporting all immigrants living in the U.S. illegally, a stance mirrored by an equal proportion in opposition.

Divided Views on Immigration: How America is Reacting to New Border Policies in 2025
Border Security and Beyond: Unpacking U.S. Immigration Priorities in 2025

Manuel Morales, a Democrat near Moline, Illinois, exemplifies the nuanced views many Americans hold. Having once crossed the border illegally nearly four decades ago, Morales expresses a deep empathy for migrants seeking a better life yet acknowledges the practical limits: “We cannot just receive everybody into this county.”

Community and Police: The Local Collaboration Debate

The poll also highlights a significant consensus on local police collaborating with federal immigration authorities under certain conditions. This collaboration is generally accepted, except in sensitive locations such as schools and churches, where the prospect of conducting arrests is broadly unpopular.

Interestingly, while a majority of Republicans favor routine cooperation between local and federal agencies, Democrats are more selective, emphasizing a situational approach to such collaborations.

Divided Views on Immigration: How America is Reacting to New Border Policies in 2025
Inside America’s Immigration Debate: Consensus and Controversy in Trump’s Second Term

Reflections from a Nation Divided

Doug DeVore, a 57-year-old Republican from southern Indiana, voices a sentiment common among many who feel uneasy about aggressive immigration checks: “There’s that fine line” between monitoring and deporting non-violent immigrants, suggesting a complex balance between enforcement and rights.